Which of Carrie's Three Dresses Do You Like Best?

12/04/2007 at 06:00 AM ET

Chris Pizzello/AP; Kevin Mazur/WireImage(2)

Carrie Underwood had not one, but three dazzling dresses at the Movie Rocks event in Los Angeles on Sunday night. She hit the red carpet in a plunging crimson Naeem Khan gown, changed into a lavish Tadashi Shoji black gown for her rendition of “The Sound of Music,” and then switched it up one more time to a glittering gold Dolce Jovani minidress to present. We love that Carrie branched out and tried new colors and silhouettes at the fashionable event, but we can’t decide which of the three dresses we like best! Tell us: Which of Carrie’s three dresses do you like best? Her red dress, black gown or gold minidress?

Add A Comment

Got something to add to this post? Fill out the fields below to make a comment, ask a question or share a tip. We'd love to hear from you.

Note: If this is your first time commenting on Style News Now, your comment will need to be approved by our moderator before it will appear. Thanks for your patience, and check back again soon.

Showing 80 comments

Hannah Delemeester on

we’ve seen so much glitter.. i’m over number 3
the simple black dress doesn’t catch my eye
so the first red dress is my favorite

Catherine on

The red Nhaeem Khan gown is my favorite of these three – wow!

Tatum on

I love them all so hard to pick but i’ll have to go with the gold i love some sparkle

Nichole on

Looks like she tried a dress for each decade of her adult years. I think the mini suits her age the best; she should save the red gown for her 30’s/40’s and the black for her 50’s/60’s!

jihkdy on

Red is my favorite but they all look beautiful! She is beautiful in anything!

elizabeth on

Those three dresses are gorgeous! She looks stunning no matter what! I probably like the metallic gold dress best and then probably the red dress! She looks great in them all though!

SpicyGem on

Love the red one!

hilary on

all of them are best!!!!!!!!!!!!
but the best of the best is carrie underwood herself!!!!!!!!!
buy her ‘CARNIVAL RIDE’ for your X-MAS gift…okay?

Jasmine on

I cannot pick a favorite – I love them all! Carrie always looks stunning – elegant and classy. What a beautiful girl and role model!

MacKenzie on

First of all she looks amazing in all 3! My favorite is the black gown.

Jessica on

They all are beautiful and she is stunning in anything but in my opinion, the red one is FABULOUS!!

guess who on

I like Carrie’s gold minidress best because it shows off her legs and is the most youthful and fun out of the three. I also like that it’s sparkly. She looks great in all 3, though. She seems very classy.

Julie on

The black is really elegant

Anna on

She looks good in all of the dresses. Not sure how flattering the gold one is, but the black is amazing!

Julie on

The one on the right. It is very age appropriate, fun, flirty, but yet very elegent.

Krystal on

I love all 3, but the red dress is my favorite. Absolutely gorgeous!

Elda on

All three look nice on her but i kinda like the red the best, she is jus gorgeous!!

Allison on

Why does her hair always look like she’s going to prom? Over it.

Rebecca on

The flappy saggy things under her arms are not so good on the red gown. The gold minidress is pretty and fun, but my favorite is black gown because of the shape. It would be even better in a different color, such as red or gold.

Karen on

Carrie is always stunning. If I have to pick one, I would say the black dress. What a classy young lady. Tony Romo what is wrong with you. Jessica Simpson does not live up to Carrie’s standards.

Judy on

Definately the BLACK dress, very classy.

len on

i love the red one but i love the other 2 too.

Alison on

Definitely the red dress. Although, she does look great in the other two as well. Carrie always looks good!

mary on

love them all

Erena on

The black dress is simple, elegant and classy. The other two are overstated.

me on

Yuck, I don’t care for any of them. They seem a little old on her. Why did she change 3 times in one night anyway? Is this what they do for attention?

Andie on

I think Carrie looks beautiful in each of these dresses-classy and sexy at the same time! I think my favorite is the red dress!

Sam on

the Red! Red is my favorite color – more bold – stands out!

Lydia on

Black one definately…she looks beautiful!

Addi on

I love her Black Dress!!!!!!

Dorothy on

Wow they all look amazing and she looks gorgeous in any of them. But for the sake of picking I will go with the red one, then with the gold one and last pick will be the black-I am just not very fond on black dresses although the detailing on this one are exquisite!

Pat on

Carrie is the next Faith Hill!!! They both look spectacular in what every thing they wear!

marie on

the gold. i hate the red’s belt, and i dont like anything about the black. the gold will have to do -shrug-.

kristin on

she looks great all the time! i love all of the dresses on her but my favorite is the gold!

Coug on

The red one – by far!!! Stunning!

Celia on

the black one!!

Anonymous on

My favorite is the red, although she is gorgeous in all of them.

Karen on

Carrie is a natural beauty and looks great in whatever she wears. Love them all………..


CRIMSON NAEEM KHAN GOWN ..Is The Best!!!!!!!!!!!!!

-Its Such A Beautiful Colour!
-Shows Off Her Figure!
-The Belt Looks Vintage!


..Looks Too Simple!


-I Dont Really Like Sequinced Anymore!

Kimmy on


Lindsay on

I like the red one the best. It’s different, but a cute different.

Kristy on

Red, hands down!


She looks beautiful in all 3 dresses. My favorite is the red dress,

Jessi on

I think Carrie looks beautiful in all three dresses. My favorite is the gold then the red and finally the black. These days she is looking so cute and sassy. GO CARRIE!!

Colleen on

The gold one! It looks so good with her hair color and I love how she wears her hair in the side ponytail! She also wears short dresses a lot.

alt on

I can’t decide between the black one and the gold one. Love them both!

Christie on

Love the red one, definitely!!

Pat on

Carrie is a beautiful young lady and looked great in all three; however, the red is my favorite.

Kell. on

She looks amazing in all.
But red one just catchs your eye.

crystal on

Not fair that she can look so great in anything she puts on!

Jaimie on

I like the gold dress, but I like the black dress at a more conservative event!

Jaylee on

Carrie looks stunning in all of them; but forced to choose, the metalic gold. Carrie is such a classy girl. She is truly a gift. I enjoy her success so much, cannot hear her music too often.

Katie on

I Love them all. I don’t she could ever look horrible. She is just gorgeous!

Deb on

I love them all! My favorite would be the red one! Carrie always looks so classy!!

Helen on

I love the black gown on Carrie she looks so sweet and lovely and it truly is her style.

Kristin on

Definitely the gold dress!

Theresa on

I love all 3 dresses— they were perfect for the occasion! But I think my personal favorite is the red dress for the Green Carpet- as it was almost Greek looking and very flattering.

jen on

i like the red one best!

jen on

i like the red one best! it is pretty!!!!!!!!

jen on

i like the red one best! it is pretty!!!!!!!! and red!!!!! yeah red!!!!!!!

Katie Oliver on

I thnik Carrie is a very beautiful woman. Its women like her Iam happy that my daughters like her,she doesn’t have to dress like a tramp like other stars out there. But if I have to pick a fave…….I would choose the gold dress! You go girl!:)

Vonnie on

i can’t decide! they are all good looking and glam


Mandy on

I like the red one, normally I think I’d like the gold one better but the way that she is posed doesn’t look the good with her. The red one is more unique too! I wish I had one.

Joo on

Carrie looks incredible in anything! Red is definitely her color though, so I’m going with the first =)

Alley on

The red dress is striking but I love the black dress. Carrie looks fabulous in all three. I totally love her hair and it’s nice to see her glowing and shining like the star she is. Carrie looks stunning in anything! Okay almost anything, she’s just a beauty.

Abby on

I love that Black dress. Not crazy about the bubble bottom on the gold one. The red would be better if it didn’t have all the extra stuff under her arms.

Debbie on

She looks beautiful in all the dresses! I think my favorite is the red. She looks awesome in red with her blonde hair. She is one class act and so talented, too!!!

nicole on

carrie looks gorgeous in all those dresses- somehow she manages to pull of three totally different looks. i only wish that she can do something more ‘wow’ with her hair. my favourite would have to be the red because it fits her beautifully and design is so creative!

Jane on

She looks radiant in all 3 of them and they are all gorgeous. I would have to say though, that the black one is my favorite.

Angelique on

i have to say that is my favorite out of the three..she looks gorgeous!

Dee on

i really love the the gold one

Haley on

I think she looks amazing in all of them, but the red one is different and stands out more.

Montserrath on

Carrie looks awesome in all the three gowns, but my favorite one is the black. It’s beautiful.

ava on

all dresses look good on her!

ava on

whatever dress Carrie wears,she always looks good.its not only the dress that Carrie wears that looks good but Carrie herself looks absolutely fabulous marvelous glamorous!

Jolian on

I like the dress.!!

Meg on

This girl would look great if she wore a paper bag. She is beautiful no matter what.

Carol on

Carrie looks ABSOLUTELY gorgeous in ALL of them! How could you ask us to pick just one? Carrie lokks good in anything, a real fashionista.

Taylor on

I like all 3, but I’m torn between the red and black. I call it a tie! I like the red because the color stands out, and the style is beautiful, and I like the gold accents around the waist. I really like the black one too. Yes, black is really simple and “safe,” but I really like the style of the dress, especially the bottom part. The black dress could be any color really and still look great.

marina on

me encanto el de naeem khan es un gran diseƱador muy talentoso.

From Our Partners


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,514 other followers

Sign up for our daily newsletter and other special offers.
    Choose your newsletters
Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.
    see all newsletters