Mischa, Jennifer and Kate's Must-Have Shirt!

05/15/2007 at 01:15 PM ET

When we spotted Kate Hudson in her buttoned-up eyelet top last fall, we thought she looked adorable — and so do Mischa Barton and Jennifer Garner in their identical shirts! All three stars snapped up (and been snapped in) this sweet Juicy Couture eyelet and chiffon blouse that’s still available to the rest of us online. Get your own at neimanmarcus.com, $228 — or get the look for less at jcrew.com, $78, and forever21.com, $23. Tell us: Who do you think wears the Juicy Couture top better: Jennifer, Kate or Mischa?

Click here to see (and vote on!) more stars in identical outfits in our Fashion Faceoff gallery.

Photo: inf; Respicio/ JFX; bfc/Finalpixx

Add A Comment

Got something to add to this post? Fill out the fields below to make a comment, ask a question or share a tip. We'd love to hear from you.

Note: If this is your first time commenting on Style News Now, your comment will need to be approved by our moderator before it will appear. Thanks for your patience, and check back again soon.

Showing 28 comments

Julie on

I LOVE that JCrew shirt! It ties at the waist so it’d make my waist look small, and it’s such a pretty fabric. And machine washable. It’s more than I can spend on clothes right now, but I love it!

enigma on

Sydney….I mean Jennifer…wears it best!! Cheers!

ucokaty on

i don’t normally like mischa’s fashion choices, but she wears this top GREAT! :) i like jennifer garner, but it looks better actually buttoned up.

MTP on

$228 for a shirt? The shirt is cute but it’s that cute!

Crystal Beach girl on

Very pretty. It’s nice to see some fem looking clothes.

Priscilla on

I like them all three!!! Probably Mischa is the last one on the list.

faith on

for once i think that mischa wears it best. cute top. too expensive.

j on

i have this juicy shirt and LOVE it, i’ve gotten compliments both times i’ve worn it. tori spelling was also photographed in it. fyi: it runs small so order a size larger than you normally would! :)

Geri on

It’s cute, but I would tire of this top in a minute. It’s just not sexy and it’s not worth the price. It looks like something my 8 yr old niece would wear.

jourdan on

I LOVEE KATEE!!Mischa wears it well too

Seldy on

Jennifer wears it the best of anyone, but over 200$ for a shirt? I would get the cheaper one, probably the JCrew one. I love the company.

adrienne day on

i just happened to be wearing this shirt today for the second time. i knew it was a must have when i first saw it. it comes in black too, but the color doesn’t do the shirt justice. i love everything that juicy makes. i even gave my sister in law one for her birthday.

Mary on

The Juicy shirt is definitely too pricey, but it also looks a LOT better than the JCrew or Forever21 shirt.

elii on

adorable on all three; definatley somethig worth saving up for, and for those who complain about it being pricey..theres a reason they put cheaper look-a-likes!

Maryse on

I like the shirt, it’s very cute and something I would wear. I like the JCrew shirt and at a much cheaper discount then $200. I’m gonna go check out both JCrew and Forever21.

I like how Kate wears it, but Mischa wears it nicely too. I thought I would never agree on anything Mischa wears, but she looks cute in the top. I like Jennifer and she wears the shirt nicely, but I think the shirt would look better buttoned up. So out of the 3, I’m gonna go with Kate.

Kate on

I have to say that I think Mischa wears it best. Though Mischa’s look has been a mess lately she looks lovely in this shirt. I don’t think I would buy this shirt myself, it’s a bit pricey and looks actually quite boring. I don’t think I would wear it a lot. Then again, I sometimes buy stuff that doesn’t fit or look good :D

natasha minogue on

These tops are really comfy. I bought 3 on my recent holiday to India…well out of the 3 i think kate looks the cutest.

Danni on

I think the J.Crew shirt looks better than the more expensive Juicy one.

Elda on

cutest shirt, i want one!! by the way all three look great with it on.

*star* on

i love this cute top! its really pretty and looks great on all 3

Maranda on


Kayla on

This shirt is lovely, i love the way jennifer wears it

bebe on

i like mischa. the shirt makes the other two look boring

Jenny on


Paige on

EWW! UGLY they all look really old in those shirts!

Paige on

EWW! UGLY they all look really old in those shirts!

Juicy Girl 4eva on

i absolutely LOVE this shirt! I have it in black bc they didn’t have my size in white at bloomingdales. juicy makes the best stuff. the eyelet makes it extremely trendy though.

Juicy Girl 4eva on

oops forgot to add that ella moss makes a top similar to this except it’s not eyelet. they sell it at nordstroms for $110. i just bought it and it’s soo gorgeous. but not as gorgeous as the juicy top. ;)

From Our Partners


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,514 other followers

Sign up for our daily newsletter and other special offers.
    Choose your newsletters
Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.
    see all newsletters